Ashley and Melody =#1?

[boni]

I dont know why? But the judges were pretty severe with Melody and Ashley. They were beautiful, they had carisma, some realy good songs, etc... The perfect Idol! For me those two were already in the top 5.

Even if their not I bet they're gonna sell more CD then anyone in a few year, because they look INTERNATIONAL. And they sound like it to.

[AI_Lover]

I felt they were rather harsh with Ashley, just b/c she didn't do as well as she could have, doesn't mean she still didn't blow all of the others out of the park. I mean think about it, if that's Ashley bad, think about a good performance.